Vet a fractional CFO by asking who does the work, what you get in writing, and what happens if you stop. Most of the cost of a wrong hire is not the fee. It is the months before you find out, and the files you cannot easily take back.
The questions, and what each protects
| Ask | A good answer | What it protects you from |
|---|---|---|
| Who is in my file week to week? | A named person with a stated background | Paying for a senior name while a junior does the work |
| What will you deliver, as a list? | Named outputs: a forecast, a reporting package, a lender model | A scope that cannot be checked |
| What do you expect my bookkeeper or controller to own? | Specific dependencies named | The CFO quietly inheriting cleanup work at CFO rates |
| What happens in a quiet month? | A written answer: reduced hours, pause, or fixed fee | A retainer that runs with nothing to decide |
| How do you work with my CPA? | A clear split between forward planning and tax filing | Tax consequences missed inside financing and sale decisions |
| What happens to the models and files if I stop? | They are yours, with access kept | An expensive exit |
| Can the first engagement have a ceiling? | Yes: a bounded 60 to 90 day scope and a dollar limit | An open-ended commitment before you have seen results |
Red flags in the answers
- Strategy first, with no question about whether your books are current.
- A promise of funding, growth or margin before inspecting the business.
- No set rhythm. A forecast reviewed once is a document, not a tool.
- Pressure to sign an open-ended retainer before any deliverable.
A rule you can reuse on the next hire
Before you sign with anyone, ask what it costs you to leave. A good hire is one you could stop paying next month without losing your files, your models or your time. If the exit is expensive, the real price is higher than the fee, whoever the person is and whatever the role.
When the opposite answer is fine
A provider who says the engagement should start with controller work is often giving you the honest answer, even though it is a smaller sale. If your last closed month is unknown, that answer is probably right. See controller vs fractional CFO.
What to have ready
Bring the last closed financial statements, receivables and payables aging, debt schedule and payroll summary, plus the one decision that started the search. If those reports do not exist, that is the useful finding. Details are on what a fractional CFO does, and fees are on what outsourced CFO help costs.
If you are not sure whether you need a controller or a CFO, the role-clarity diagnostic at GetAFractional asks a short set of questions and surfaces the right next step.
This page is informational and is not financial, legal, or tax advice. Ask your accountant about tax and entity questions.