Hire a fractional CFO if you need someone to keep owning a finance decision month after month. Hire a finance consultant if you need one defined piece of work finished and handed back. The choice is between ongoing ownership and a finish line. Each costs you something the other does not.
The two choices side by side
| Fractional CFO | Finance consultant | |
|---|---|---|
| What you get | A standing decision partner: forecast, cash watch, lender and pricing conversations, kept current | One deliverable: a model, a review, a plan, a report |
| Who owns the result | Shared with you, month after month | You, once the deliverable is handed over |
| What it costs you that no bill shows | A retainer keeps running in months when nothing needed deciding | The work goes stale; updating it later means paying again or doing it yourself |
| How hard it is to undo | Depends on the notice terms you agreed | Easy: it ends when the deliverable is delivered |
| What stays behind | A routine: forecast updates, named assumptions | A document |
| Best when | The same decision keeps coming back (cash, hiring, pricing) | One event with a date (a lender request, a sale, a turnaround plan) |
When the opposite choice is right
If you already have a question with a date on it, a consultant's fixed scope is usually the cleaner buy, and a retainer for it is the costlier way to get the same answer. If your decisions keep returning, a one-off report ages quickly and you end up buying the same discovery work twice.
Check this before either
Both options assume your numbers can support the work. If last month is not closed and trusted, you are paying a senior person to discover that, and the fix is a different role. The controller vs fractional CFO page covers that line, and what a fractional CFO does covers the engagement itself. For what each costs, see what outsourced CFO help costs.
A habit you can reuse
Before hiring anyone, write the decision as one sentence and ask: will it come back, or is it a one-time event? Recurring means ownership. One-time means a finish line.
Not sure which finance role fits your situation? The role-clarity diagnostic at GetAFractional asks a short set of questions and surfaces the right next step.
This page is informational and is not financial, legal, or tax advice. Ask your accountant about the tax treatment of any engagement.